5-grid Samurai Skyscraper
Samurai 5-grid Skyscraper puzzle
I thought I’d try one more Skyscraper Samurai Sudoku puzzle – this time a 5-grid variety, or what I think of as the ‘traditional’ Samurai Sudoku format (some people also call this Gattai-5, but I’ve not seen that in print anywhere).
The aim is to place 1 to 9 into each row, column and 3×3 bold-lined box of each of the 5 9×9 Sudoku grids, whilst also obeying the Skyscraper constraints. These tell you the number of digits that can be ’seen’ from the edge of the grid looking in along the adjacent row/column, where higher numbers obscure lower ones. Take a look at a couple of last week’s puzzles if you need more detailed instructions for this constraint.
As has been pointed out in the comments elsewhere, it doesn’t matter whether you consider that the Skyscraper clues apply to the nearest 9×9 grid or to the entire width/height of the row/column they attach to – once the first ‘9′ is reached then there are no higher numbers, and that’s guaranteed to happen within the first 9 squares.
I think this is probably about as large as you want to go with a relatively complex constraint such as Skyscraper, which is why I’ve included quite a few given numbers too – including some which clearly aren’t needed to give the puzzle a unique solution. (But please tell me if I’m wrong about this being big enough – I could always make a much larger one still just to prove that it’s possible!)
This week I plan to try out some other types of consecutive Sudoku variant – there are a couple of moderately-well-known types where you specify certain relationships between adjacent squares, such as ‘x2′ (where one number is twice the adjacent one – a bit like a slightly less-constrained version of consecutive sudoku!). If you have any ideas for other variants, feel free to let me know – I might try them out!
Good luck!
Comments are closed.
about 15 years ago
A real challenge this one! (For me, anyway!) Three days later and I’m still working on it – only just completed the bottom left hand grid but am gradually chipping away at the rest. Great fun, thank you!
about 15 years ago
Pretty amazing effort! I can send you the solution if that would help – I find with big, tough puzzles I lose momentum unless I keep reassuring myself I haven’t gone wrong!
about 15 years ago
Yes please! That would be great – there’s nothing worse than spending hours on a puzzle only to find you’ve made an error in the end. I’ve got most of the 9s, 8s and 7s in – it’s those low numbers that are causing all the trouble!!!
P.S. Looking forward to starting the 5 grid consecutive puzzle! My favourite type of the moment!
about 15 years ago
Solution sent!
about 15 years ago
Took a while, but I got it! I am still wrapping my head around tower techniques to merge with sudoku ones. In this one you must use skyscraper info all the way through and not just for the beginning or the end since there are many unique rectangles otherwise.
I liked the workout, but perhaps a smaller puzzle that can be done in less time is the sweet spot? …
about 15 years ago
Congratulations! I do agree that this one was too hard. Smaller grids are definitely better for solving, but I do still want to put some really outlandish puzzles on the blog to try and find out where the boundaries are!
Today’s 13-grid Killer Sudoku Pro Toroidal Samurai puzzle is a case in point – it’s more of an exhibition piece than a puzzle I expect many people to want to solve (although for those people who love these huge puzzles, it should hopefully be great fun!).